This is the third in a series addressing misconceptions found in nativity narratives and most nativity scenes. The first week addressed Misconceptions About Mary and Joseph’s Journey to Bethlehem and the second week focused on Misconceptions about the Place of Jesus’ Birth.
The Beauty of Nativity Scenes
Now don’t hear me wrong and don’t put away your nativity scenes. Don’t skip the Christmas pageants and, please, don’t criticize the way they tell the Christmas story! The message of Jesus coming to earth, as an infant born of a virgin, is accurate…even if some of the other details are amiss. The purpose for addressing these misconceptions is so we don’t base our theology on man’s narratives. Instead, always be a Berean and check the Scriptures to determine what is true (Acts 17:11).
Enjoy the Christmas narratives, allow nativity scenes to inspire awe and wonder, but always hold closely to the truths revealed in the Bible. The Bible does not give all-inclusive information about Jesus’ birth, but the Bible does give fully-sufficient information to know that Jesus humbled Himself and came to earth to seek and save the lost. He came to be Emmanuel—God with us. Rejoice in the great sacrifice of God that brought salvation to mankind.
The Most Important Lesson of the Nativity
This week we address who was there when the King of kings was born, and who came to see the Baby lying in the manger.
Please read to the end of this article and watch the video. You’ll find the answer to the most important question about the Nativity….
Were YOU there when Jesus was born?
Many are familiar with the old Negro Spiritual, “Were You There When They Crucified My Lord?” (If you have not heard this song, there’s a link below.) It’s a hauntingly beautiful and moving song that speaks of “coming to the cross” and remembering all that Jesus did in His sacrificial love for us and in service to His Father’s will.
But do we “come to the cradle” in the same way that we “come to the cross?”
Without the Christmas Cradle there would be no Calvary Cross.
“Coming to the cradle” involves remembering Jesus’ great sacrifice. His sacrifice wasn’t just about His death on the cross. Jesus’ sacrifice started when He left glory and entered into humanity as a Baby born into the humblest of circumstances.
As we look forward to Christmas Day, let’s go backward—back thousands of years to Bethlehem. Like the shepherds, let’s make haste to come and see “the babe lying in a manger” (Luke 2:16). Let’s consider who was there on the day when Salvation came into our world and then let’s consider what it means for us to “be there.”
1. Was there an angel over the place where Jesus was born?
Nativity scenes usually feature one of two things above the stable–either an angel or a star. Both are technically incorrect because the Bible doesn’t report that either were present (but they might have been).
We know that an angel told the shepherds in the field of Jesus’ birth and then a multitude of angels praised God (Luke 2:9-14). The Bible also tells us that this multitude of angels returned to Heaven and that only the shepherds set out for Bethlehem to “see this thing which is come to pass, which the Lord hath made known unto us” (Luke 2:15).
There is nothing to suggest an angel appeared above the place where Jesus was born, or that angels were present. However, just because the Bible doesn’t report the presence of an angel or angels, it is possible that angels were there at the birth of Jesus, as is portrayed in many Nativity narratives. In fact, it seems highly likely that angels would have been there as ministering spirits (Hebrews 1:14) even if they did not appear to those present.
Regarding the star that adorns so many Nativity scenes, we don’t know if it was present. The Bible only tells that the star led the Wise Men and it came to rest above the place where they found Jesus (Matthew 2:9). It is most likely this was some time after Jesus’ birth. We know the star appeared after Jesus was born (Matthew 2:2) and it first led the Wise Men to Jerusalem where they inquired of King Herod, “Where is he that is born King of the Jews?” (Matthew 2:2). The star then continued to lead the Wise Men. But the Bible does not tell how long their journey was before the star came to rest above above the place where they found Jesus. It is reasoned to have been some length of time after Jesus’ birth, perhaps four to 24 months later.
2. Were there sheep, goats and cows gathered around the manger?
Almost all nativity scenes and Christmas pageants feature sheep present, and many include goats and cows. If they include the Wise Men, camels are often present too.
The Bible does not say that animals were present at the Lord’s birth. However, because Jesus was laid in a feeding trough used for animals, it’s very reasonable to think that there could have been some animals in the shelter in which Jesus was born. Therefore, the presence of animals around the manger on the night in which Jesus was born is likely, but not certain because it is not reported in the Bible.
3. Were the shepherds and the Wise Men there on the night Jesus was born?
When the shepherds were told by an angel of Jesus’ birth (Luke 2:8-13) they went immediately to Bethlehem. We do not know how long it took them, but it is safe to assume they arrived shortly after Jesus’ birth, because the Bible tells us they were “in the same country” and “they came with haste” (Luke 2:8-16).
The Wise Men are a different story. When did they arrive?
The answer is, we don’t know. What we do know is that the star appeared to the Wise Men when Jesus was born and they saw it and began their journey to follow it.
Early church tradition claims that the journey took 12 days. Based on this the early church set a commemoration day of the Wise Men’s arrival and called it Epiphany, meaning manifestation or appearance. The 12 days is, however, simply tradition born from legend (It is from this tradition that we get the song, The Twelve Days of Christmas).
Many contend that the Wise Men traveled for months—first to Jerusalem and then to the place where they saw Jesus. Some even believe it was years. The biblical chronology on this is not clear. We do know that Jesus was dedicated in the Temple at 40 days old (after the wait of eight days for circumcision of a boy child and 33 days for Mary’s purification). It is therefore reasoned, that if the Wise Men had already presented their gifts of great worth to Baby Jesus, Joseph and Mary would have had enough money to purchases a lamb as a sacrificial offering to God. Instead Joseph and Mary gave the provision that was made for the poor (Leviticus 12:8), which was to offer two birds — either a pair of turtledoves or pigeons. (Luke 2:22-24). If they had already received the valuable gifts from the Wise Men, they would have been able to purchase the preferred lamb to offer to God.
For more information about the Wise Men read:
- How did the Wise Men know this was the Messiah and how did they know to follow His star?
- What is the significance of the Three Kings’ gifts?
- Who were the Three Wise Men? Fact or legend?
Were YOU there when Jesus was born?
We know Mary was there. We know Joseph was there. We know the Shepherds arrived shortly after Jesus’ birth and the Wise Men came some time later. Of course we know you were not there at the time when Jesus was born. But what if you had been? How would you respond?
The Season of Advent (the 4 weeks before Christmas)
What is Advent?
HOPE Advent Candle 1 – Prophecy Gives Hope (video)
LOVE Advent Candle 2 – Promise Reveals Love (video)
JOY Advent Candle 3 – Jesus Is Our Joy (video)
PEACE Advent Candle 4 – Pause to Find Peace (video)
Christmas Day: When Love Was Born — Light the CHRIST Candle (video)
What is the Prophetic Symbolism of Advent Candles?
How Do We “Take” Advent and Find Rest?
Download a Daily Devotional for Advent
Download “King of Love” Daily Advent Devotions
A Christmas Poem to Download and Print
Christmas-themed GOT QUESTIONS?
- What are the Events of Jesus’ Birth? A Simple Timeline and Chronology
- Misconceptions about the Journey to Bethlehem (video)
- What do Zelophehad’s Daughters have to do with Christmas?
- Errors in the Nativity Story? Is Jesus’ birthplace wrong?
- Who were the Three Wise Men? Fact or legend?
- How Did the Wise Men Know to Follow His Star?
- Did The Wise Men Arrive 12 Days After Jesus’ Birth? Or Was It Much Later?
- What is the significance of the Three Kings' gifts?
- Was Jesus born in a stable, a cave, or a house?
- Should we celebrate Jesus’ birthday in September?
- Was Jesus born in September (not December?)
- Does “Xmas” Cross Jesus Out of Christmas?
- What is the Prophetic Symbolism of Advent Candles?
- The Most Important Lesson for YOU in the Nativity Story?
- Was Mary a Levite, making Jesus both King and Priest?
- Should Christians Celebrate Christmas?
- How did Jesus become a man?
- Do You Get These 7 Things Right or Wrong About the Nativity Story?
- Are You Stuck in the Middle This Christmas? (short video lessons from the popular comedy TV show "The Middle.")
- What are the Prophecies of Christmas? (video)
- Where are the genealogies of Jesus in Mark and John?
- Why Are There Two Different Genealogies for Jesus?
- Should I Say “Happy Holidays” Instead of “Merry Christmas?
- “Immanuel” — A Poem by Charles Spurgeon (1834-1892)
- Who’s Often Forgotten in the Birth of Jesus Story?
- Why is Simeon Significant in the Nativity Narrative?
- Why is Anna Significant in the Nativity Narrative?
- Scripture Cookies – Fun for the Whole Family!
- A Boastful Christmas Letter
- Peace Delivers Hope
- Promise Ignites Hope
- Preparation Produces Hope
- Prophesy Reveals Hope
- Alone at Christmas? Feeling lonely?
- Another reason God came to dwell with man.
- How can you have a white Christmas without snow?
- Christmas, abortion, and Joseph, the forgotten man of Christmas
- Remember the Wonder of Christmas
- Will you find rest, peace, and joy this advent season?
- A Christmas Morning Prayer by Robert Louis Stevenson (1850-1894)
- The Christmas Story in Poetic Verse, by Alvy E. Ford (1918-2005)
- Need a Quick Christmas Letter with a Significant Message?
- It All Happened in a Moment
- T’was the Night Before Jesus Came
Christmas Word Search Puzzles
- The Most Beautiful O Holy Night O Night Divine, when Christ was Born
- A Baby Changes Everything, by Faith Hill
- Mary, Did You Know?
- While You Were Sleeping — A Wake Up Call for America
- I Heard the Bells on Christmas Day, by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, performed by Casting Crowns
- Mary’s Child — from the movie, A Christmas Wish
- The True Meaning of Christmas: The Sacrifice Began (How Many Kings)
- What If You Had Been There When Jesus Was Born? (video)
- Pause to Find Hope. Receive the Promises of God. See Jesus. Hear God’s Plan.
- Christmas Trivia Fun
- Songs of Christmas Series: Away in a Manger; Mary, Did You Know? The Rose of Bethlehem; Good Christian Men Rejoice; Hark! The Herald Angels Sing; I Wonder As I Wander; What Child Is This? The First Noel; In the Bleak Midwinter (a golden oldie)
Have You Heard About This Baby Boy? A most beautiful rendition of Leonard Cohen's Hallelujah, with a Christmas message to touch your heart and give joy to your soul.
Jesus is the Reason this Ministry Exists
At Reasons for Hope* Jesus, we are committed to equipping, encouraging, and empowering Christians to know Jesus better, love Him more, and share their faith. We also reach the lost through our Salvation Page.
With your support, we can continue to provide valuable resources and engaging content. Please join us in our mission by donating today. Your generous contribution helps us expand our outreach of sharing biblical truths and hope in Jesus. Thank you for your kindness and for being an integral part of our mission.
***A Hidden Message in Psalm 23?***
Hidden in the six verses of Psalm 23 are 11 names for Jesus. When you subscribe to our newsletter, we’ll send you The Names of God in Psalm 23 PDF that reveals all 11 names and Scripture verses of comfort and hope (link will be sent in your confirmation email).
A Room with a View of Eternity—The Last Will & Testament of Jesus Christ Take a seat at the Master's table. Learn about the riches He gives to all who are His. This book will bless and encourage you, give you hope, and help you live in the joy of your salvation and the riches of Christ that are yours.
The Top Ten Got Questions? in 2023
- The Meaning of NUMBERS in the Bible?
- Was Jesus CRUCIFIED on Wednesday, Thursday, or Friday?
- How was Jesus Like a Worm? What’s the CRIMSON (OR SCARLET) WORM in Psalm 22?
- How are the Shepherd’s ROD and STAFF Different?
- How long did JOB SUFFER?
- What is the Significance of the Wise Men's THREE GIFTS? And were they kings?
- Did The Wise Men Arrive 12 DAYS AFTER JESUS’ BIRTH? Or Was It Much Later?
- Jesus’ Last Days TIMELINE: the Cross and the Resurrection
- The Meaning of COLORS in the Bible?
- Did Jesus Fight Satan to Take Back the KEYS of Death and Hell?
There is much to be learned from those who have gone before us in the faith. Check out our Cloud of Witnesses category that features the words of departed saints who are now with the Lord in glory. Their words equip and encourage us even to this day. Take a few minutes to hear...
- ONLY ONE LIFE, Twill Soon Be Past – by C.T. Studd (1860 – 1931)
- “The Love of God is Greater Far” by Frederick M. Lehman (1917)
- Prayers from Billy Graham
- Who Was Robert Robinson? What’s the Story Behind “Come Thou Fount”
- “Immanuel” — A Poem by Charles Spurgeon (1834-1892)
- Who Am I? A Poem by Deitrich Bonhoeffer (1905-1945)
- Understanding the Everlasting Arms of God, by J.R. Miller (1840–1912)
- 24 Reasons Why I Love America, by John Wayne (1907-1979)
- Give Me Perpetual Broken-heartedness (from The Valley of Vision)
- Abide with Me, by James Smith, 1859
TOP TEN Videos from Reasons for Hope* Jesus
- Memorial Day BAGPIPES TRIBUTE: Amazing Grace
- RISE AND SHINE and Give God the Glory, Glory!
- WERE YOU THERE When They Crucified My Lord?
- PAUL HARVEY: THE BIRDCAGE
- PRESIDENT RONALD REAGAN: A SOLDIER'S PLEDGE
- Hark! the Herald Angels Sing -- CHARLIE BROWN Christmas
- JOHN WAYNE ~ WHY I LOVE AMERICA
- Jimmy Stewart - Nativity Scene Prayer: Mr. Krueger's Christmas
- THE LEGEND OF THE CANDY CANE - A Christmas Story to Share
- Not by Might, Not by Power, But BY MY SPIRIT says the Lord (Zechariah 4:6)